'Nothing is ever quite the same after you've been elsewhere, is it?'
We meet Margot Rosenthal and her father in London, and follow them to Paris
in 1919, where her academic Papa Professor Rosenthal is assisting in an
advisory capacity as a diplomat with the conference where the world's leaders
have come together to try and move forwards after World War I. The bulk of
the story is set in Paris and Versailles, and the final part is set back in
Berlin, where Margot's Jewish family is from.
It is her days in Paris that will change Margot's life and her view of the
world. There she meets Krysia, an enigmatic pianist who Margot is drawn to, feeling
lonely and seeking friendship in this unfamiliar city where she is still
regarded by many as the enemy. She also meets Captain Georg Richwalder, a handsome
young naval officer who served in the war and is now working with the German
delegation at the conference. There is an immediate and strong mutual
attraction between Margot and Georg, but Margot holds back, feeling guilty that
back home, her wounded fiancé Stefan is waiting for her. She is torn between
her duty and commitment to him, made in haste pre-war, and the newfound, more
passionate emotions she feels for Georg. She spends many hours working with
him, assisting with translating some key documents.
Through the changes in Georg, as observed by Margot, Pam Jenoff writes perceptively
of how innocent young men were irrevocably changed by their experiences in the
war:
'"I was studying at university when the war broke out." His eyes
have a faraway look and his voice sounds like mine when I speak of travel. I
see him then as a boy, wide-eyed and bright with a future in front of him. He
is so broken now, like so many others. I am seized by the urge to take him into
my arms. Can he be healed or is he too far gone?'
Georg is only in his mid twenties now, but feels like an older, broken man
in some ways. His work at the conference has given him some purpose again, as
he searches desperately for some good to have come from the war; 'It has
to have meant something, doesn't it?' The story also touches on the
restrictions on a woman's life and choices back then.
Margot is very close to her father, her mother having passed away years
before as she understands it. Yet she suspects that her father keeps things
from her, as she herself has now begun to keep things from him. Their
relationship is subject to much change and damage as the story unfolds.
'There is no one in the world to whom I feel closer than Papa. Yet despite
our deep affection, there are vast areas of darkness, things unsaid, parts of
ourselves that we cannot share. Once upon a time the idea of keeping secrets
from Papa was unfathomable...Our trust is a thread that, once pulled at, is
swiftly unraveling.'
Margot makes for a flawed, passionate, interesting and at times frustrating
lead character. The narrative is written in the first-person, so we have only
her take on everything, and she is at times very independent, yet at other
times quite naïve and uncertain of herself. Her inadvertent mention to new
acquaintances introduced to her via Krysia of matters that she ought to have
kept to herself leads to her being blackmailed and becoming embroiled in
deception involving those she cares about, leading to a heavy sense of guilt
and anxiety.
Her relative youth and inexperience is reflected in the way she struggles
to commit to one course of action, and a lot of the narrative has her debating
internally as to what course she ought to take. When her fiancé Stefan
re-enters her life, there is a sense that he is a 'long outstanding bill,
now come due', a rushed commitment in her past, made too quickly due to
the war, that she now feels obliged to fulfill, not through feelings of love
but through duty and guilt. I could sympathise to some extent about her
indecision though, and her conflicting feelings; after all, she is only twenty
years old. By the end of the story though, she begins at last to find her own
strength.
Although I wasn’t sure about aspects of the events towards the end - one in
particular felt just too convenient in a way - overall I did really enjoy
becoming immersed in this historical tale with its romance and mystery; I was
intrigued as to what path Margot would take, and how the different plots that
made up the novel would develop and conclude. In particular it was interesting
to read something set at this pivotal time in history, and in these history-laden
cities, facing up to the aftermath of the Great War. There is a hint that
Georg, so unhappy by the conference’s conclusions, is leaning towards certain
sympathies in Germany at that time, and bearing in mind Margot’s religion, I
wonder if this is taken up again in Kommandant’s
Girl, to which this novel is the prequel, and which I will try to read one
day.
This is a good tale weaving together a key point in history with romance,
mystery, desire and love versus loyalty and duty, with lies and secrets, dangerous
encounters, and self-discovery; a young woman finding herself, making friends,
learning who she can and cannot trust, and falling in love. It boasts an
attractive, atmospheric cover design, too.
Published by Harlequin Mira
Thanks to Sophie at ED PR for kindly sending me a copy of this novel to read and give an honest review.
You can find the author on twitter @PamJenoff and visit her website here.
A big fan of historical fiction as you know, this sounds like my kind of read. Great review, thanks for the recommendation.
ReplyDeleteThanks for commenting Tracy, this could certainly be up your street too.
DeleteNice review, Lindsay. The book seems to look at an important historical moment through the eyes of its characters. Nice to know that it is part of a series. After reading your review, I am getting tempted to read the book. Thanks for this wonderful review.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the kind comment Vishy. I think I'll try the next book at some point.
DeleteLovely review. I like the cover of the book, and the story sounds interesting too
ReplyDeleteThanks for commenting Melinda. Yes I thought the cover was really attractive.
Delete