Published by Duckworth
Guest review by Mandy Jenkinson
Dmitri Bystrolyotov was one of the Great Illegals, a group
of Soviet spies operating in the West between the two world wars. He was
recruited in the 1920s and went on to lead a quite extraordinary life. He was a
larger-than-life figure, courageous, charismatic, a master of seduction (he
invented the modern “honey trap”), handsome, resourceful, and above all a
committed Communist, dedicated to the service of his motherland.
Much of the trajectory of his life as a spy seems stranger
than fiction, and that, for me, was one of the problems of this book. Emil
Draitser has done an impressive amount of painstaking research, but still
relies in part on Bystrolotov’s own memoirs, and Bystrolyotov is an unreliable
narrator par excellence. He contacted the author back in the 1970s shortly
before Draitser’s emigration hoping he would take on the task of writing his
biography. Thirty years later and with increased access to the archives after
the fall of the Soviet Union, Draitser set about the task. He admits to not
being able to verify some of the events, but too often allows himself the
luxury of speculating. Reconstructed conversations (which always sound false
and stilted), cod psychological explanations of Bystrolyotov’s motives and
actions, too much reliance on the memoirs, all made me distrustful.
Reading the tagline “The Secret History of Russia’s Most
Daring Spy”, I expected the book to be more thrilling and exciting than it actually
is. I was soon bored by the accounts of one incredible exploit after another. I
found the book more interesting after Bystrolyotov’s ill-advised return to the
Soviet Union, where instead of being feted for all he had done for his country,
he fell foul of Stalin’s paranoia and was arrested and sent to the Gulag. His
ordeal in the far North makes for some gripping reading. But essentially I just
couldn’t engage with this man. He never truly came alive for me. Perhaps that’s
inevitable with someone who spent much of his life pretending to be someone he
wasn’t, and just as it’s impossible to really enter the heart and mind of many
another super-spy, such as Kim Philby, perhaps such a biography is always doomed
to partial failure. I would have liked to see more illustrations, but perhaps
theses weren’t available.
Nevertheless, in spite of my reservations, this is an
intriguing look into the world of high-level espionage, and a glimpse, at
least, into the secretive world of Soviet intelligence. A pity about the lurid
cover, though, one hardly appropriate for a serious biography.
Many thanks to Mandy for reading and reviewing this novel for The Little Reader Library. Mandy is an omnivorous reader who enjoys reviewing, for newbooks magazine as well as elsewhere, and enjoys discovering new authors.
Many thanks to Mandy for reading and reviewing this novel for The Little Reader Library. Mandy is an omnivorous reader who enjoys reviewing, for newbooks magazine as well as elsewhere, and enjoys discovering new authors.
