Bookish thoughts on Three Things About Elsie by Joanna Cannon

Three Things About Elsie is filled with some lovely touches of humour, poignancy, and perceptive observations on life.

As well as this, it invites the reader into a mystery regarding a man from our main character Florence's past.

Florence is in her eighties and living in managed accommodation for the elderly. Elsie is her best friend - this is the first of the three things about her. As the book commences, Florence has fallen in her flat, and she is thinking about recent events in her life, telling us about Elsie, and about another friend in the flats, Jack, and also about a new arrival, a man who brings back past memories for Florence and causes her to embark on solving a mystery buried in her past, if she can just reach within her mind and find the answers. 

Joanna Cannon writes with warmth and in a compassionate, honest way in dealing with dementia and ageing, as well as portraying the bonds of friendship and companionship. 

There are many beautiful observations and expressions once again in Joanna Cannon's writing, as I found there were in the author’s debut novel, The Trouble with Goats and Sheep, but this time, for me, there is a stronger and more compelling story to go with it.

I enjoyed the stories woven in about the side characters of Miss Ambrose and Handy Simon, both with their issues of self-doubt and self-discovery, though I felt I would have liked to know a little more about Jack, for him to have felt just a little more fleshed out as a character. 

The book cover is a lovely appealing design of Battenberg cake which was very tempting every time I looked at the pattern, and the jigsaw pieces emblematic of Florence trying to piece together the past and find that missing piece in her present.

As I said, there were some lovely expressions and thoughts on life, many sentences and passages I marked as I read and which caused me to pause and think, some of which I've shared below.

__________

Some of my favourite pieces of writing from the book:

'She always wore cheerful clothes, it was just a shame her face never went along with it.'

'A small existence, disappeared. There was nothing left to say she'd even been there. Everything was exactly as it had been before. As if someone had put a bookmark in her life and slammed it shut.'

'We'd only been there ten minutes and my mind started to wander. It can't help itself. It very often goes for a walk without me, and before I've realised what's going on, it's miles away.'

'Elsie's father left for the war and returned as a telegram on the mantelpiece.'

'But sometimes life takes you along a path you only intended to glance down on your way to somewhere else, and when you look back, you realise the past wasn't the straight line you thought it might be. If you're lucky, you eventually move forward, but most of us cross from side to side, tripping up over our second thoughts as we walk through life.'

'It's strange, because you can put up with all manner of nonsense in your life, all sorts of sadness, and you manage to keep everything on board and march through it, then someone is kind to you and it's the kindness that makes you cry. It's the tiny act of goodness that opens a door somewhere and lets all the misery escape.'

'It didn't take them long to undo my life. I had spent eighty years building it, but within weeks, they made it small enough to fit into a manila envelope and take along to meetings.'

'...perhaps it's only in the silence that you're able to hear just how loud your own worrying is.'

'Nothing he had a go at seemed to fit. Life sometimes felt like trying on the entire contents of a shoe shop, but all of them pinched your toes.'

Dominion - C. J. Sansom

‘They can’t do this. Not here, not in England.’

Imagine a Britain with a recent past that is quite unlike the one we know…

It is 1952, and Britain has taken a different direction; an alternative history prevails here. One that sees Britain allied with Germany, Churchill not Prime Minister but instead a wanted man who is relegated to leading the British Resistance movement, Britain having surrendered to Nazi Germany in the war that began in 1939 after only one year. The government consists of right-wing fascists, appeasers and businessmen. There are ‘Nazi fingers in every dark corner of the state.’ There is no freedom of the press or unions, and protestors to the regime are dealt with harshly by the cruel Auxiliary police. There are rumours that British Jews may be moved to detention camps soon.

David Fitzgerald is a civil servant in the Dominions Office. He is also a spy for the Resistance. Sarah, David’s wife, is a pacifist like her father. She mourns, as David does, for the son they lost in a tragic accident. She seems opposed to the violence that the Resistance is increasingly turning to in order to make themselves heard. David argues: ‘What are people supposed to do? We’ve let it all go. Democracy, independence, freedom.’ Alongside their greater personal struggles, there is the question of whether their marriage can survive all that they have been through.

Frank Muncaster is a research scientist who has recently been shut away in a mental hospital. He has attracted the interest of both the Resistance and the Germans. What caused this quiet man to push his older brother Edgar through the window of his flat, what did Edgar say to him? Edgar had come back home to England from his job as a prominent scientist in America after their mother died, to deal with her affairs. What is the secret which Frank now knows, and why is it of such great importance to all sides? In fleshing out Frank’s background, the novel touches on public schools, spiritualism, and loneliness.

Gunther Hoth is the determined, driven Gestapo Sturmbannfuehrer brought over to England with a mission to track down Frank and discover just what he knows.

An array of strong characters represents the viewpoints of all sides. From those fighting for the resistance, to pacifists, to supporters of the government, to those who choose to look the other way and do nothing, to Germans, all are brought into the story, and so many carry weighty secrets. Barriers are broken down as Resistance fighters from all backgrounds come together to provide a network of safety and assistance to each other.

The world is unrecognizable. Will British values survive? Will Britain follow the lead of Germany in the abhorrent treatment of Jews? There is such fear on the streets. People are encouraged to spy on their neighbours, to report any suspicious activity. Those in power control all the news reported on the radio, television and in the press.

For David, there is the stark realization that he longs to believe none of this is real, but it is:

‘He understood suddenly how much of him, all this time, had remained anchored to the world he had been brought up in and longed, deep inside, to believe still existed: Britain, his country, dull and self-absorbed, ironic even about it’s own prejudices. But that Britain was gone, had instead turned into a place where an authoritarian government in league with Fascist thugs thrived on nationalist dreams of Empire, on scapegoats and enemies. And he was now, irrevocably, an enemy.’

London is heavy with smog, the gloom adding intensity to the frightening atmosphere, not knowing who is hiding where, who will appear out of the night?

There is tension throughout and this builds dramatically towards the thrilling finale as the assembled group of diverse characters we have come to know and cheer for must fight for their lives.

C. J. Sansom is masterful at creating and sustaining suspense; at making you turn the page, leaving you wanting more. He did this in Winter in Madrid and has done it again here. I found this a compulsive, frightening thriller; it is exciting, gripping stuff that had me turning the pages very quickly, fearful of what was to come and yet desperate to find out. The author re-writes history and depicts these momentous events so convincingly through the lives of these ordinary people, these ‘brave people with secrets’. Powerful themes run through this novel; most dominant are the divides of class, nationality, race and religion.

A thrilling and astounding re-imagining of our recent past.

Reviewed by Lindsay Healy

Published by Mantle, an imprint of Pan Macmillan

Here's a link to an article by the author about this book.

Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy of this novel to read and review.