Book Reviews

‘The best moments in reading are when you come across something - a thought, a feeling, a way of looking at things - which you had thought special and particular to you. And now, here it is, set down by someone else, a person you have never met, someone even who is long dead. And it is as if a hand has come out, and taken yours.’ Alan Bennett

“Many a book is like a key to unknown chambers within the castle of one’s own self.” ― Franz Kafka

Wednesday 8 February 2012

The Story of Beautiful Girl - Rachel Simon



It is 1968, in Pennsylvania, USA, and one evening, widow and retired teacher Martha Zimmer answers a knock at her door. It's very unusual indeed for her to have visitors, in fact it's usually just on Christmas Day when she has an open house for her former students to visit her. The unexpected visitors who suddenly arrive from nowhere will change the rest of her life. Lynnie and Homan, the visitors, have escaped from the nearby 'School for the Incurable and Feebleminded.' They have formed a bond despite the barriers and difficulties of communication between them. And they have with them a precious cargo, Lynnie's newborn baby girl. They have been there only a short while when people from the School find them and try to take them back. But Lynnie is able to force out the words 'Hide her' to Martha, and the baby stays safely with Martha as Lynnie is dragged away, and Homan runs for his freedom. 

The story moves forward then, all told through the third person narrator, in chapters which alternate between the characters Martha, Lynnie, Homan and Kate, who is an assistant at the School. Having been institutionalised for so long, it is a new and daunting world for Homan as he struggles to cope on the outside. We are told what happened to him in the past and how he came to end up in the School. Likewise with Lynnie, who is returned to the School, where she communicates with Kate through her artwork alone, we are given an insight into her earlier years, and the way in which she came to be there too. For both of them, it is inevitably a tale of sadness, and their lives at the School are very limited, and very unhappy. They suffer at the hands of those who are supposedly their carers, as there was little insight then into how to help them with their mental disabilities, and they were routinely treated with cruelty rather than supported or nurtured. Lynnie is fortunate that in Kate, she has someone who does care, and spends a little time with her trying to bring out the person inside. Meanwhile, kindly Martha is left with a newborn infant to care for, and has to act fast and decisively. She is aided by the kindness of some of her former students. 

The story moves about quite a lot, so we can learn what has happened to each of the key characters. I did feel that this made the book a little disjointed at times though, and also that I engaged much more with the stories of Lynnie and Martha than that of Homan, and when reading certain chapters I wanted to get back to the other stories; it jumped around a little too much. Lynnie is portrayed as very perceptive for a character that is suffering from an intellectual disability, perhaps too much at times to be convincing. I felt the plot was a little slow at times too, and would have liked to engage with it more. Though a very worthwhile story to tell, and very engaging at the start, I felt it needed more to keep it enthralling through to the end.  

Thinking about the issues raised in this novel, it's the proximity of the date that shocks me the most. As recently as the late 1960's and early 1970's, these institutions still existed, and the inhumane, terribly unkind treatment of the people who were forced to live there, having no other option, is deeply saddening. I feel the author has tackled an important issue in discussing this shameful past treatment of some of society's most vulnerable people, bringing it to a wide audience through her story. She talks in the notes at the end of the book about why this is of such a personal importance to her, and she has evidently researched the background very thoroughly. 


3/5

Thank you very much to WHSmith for sending me a copy of this book to read and review.

Published by Windmill Books. 

It is available to buy now from WHSmith, the paperback currently priced at £3.99.

This novel is one of the 'Richard & Judy Book Club' selections for Spring 2012. 

12 comments:

  1. Thank you for your thoughtful, balanced review, Lindsay. This has been a tentative addition to my wishlist but I think I'll remove it now, too many other more intriuging reads jostling to grab my attention!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Treez, that's kind. I was just a bit disappointed really, and as you say there are so many other reads shouting out to us all! x

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great review Lindsay! I really want to read this book! I love stories that focus on issues and leave us thinking about things.

    Megan @ Storybook Love Affair

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks Megan, it really does make you think. x

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sounds like a very different book. Your review is lovely. Very comprehensive.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dana. Was a bit different this one.

      Delete
  6. Ooh, how did you get WHSmith to send you books? I'm a bit jealous!

    This one got a lot of hype from bloggers when it was first released, so it's good to see your more balanced view of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They put a message out on twitter about reviewing and I applied and was lucky enough to get a book.
      Thanks Sam. I had heard a lot about it and it was good to have the chance to read it.

      Delete
  7. I have a copy of this on my book shelf - great review Lindsay.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Look forward to hearing what you think Josie.
      Thanks x

      Delete
  8. We have very close reviews on this, I felt the same hon. Great review as always.

    Lainy http://www.alwaysreading.net

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Lainy. Yep I think I had a very similar reaction to this one as you did.

      Delete

Thank you so much for taking the time to visit and leave a comment. It's great reading your comments and I really appreciate them :)